Review of CFC-12: Metadata on Distributed Emissions

A. McCulloch

Emission Functions

CFC-12 (CCl2F2, dichlorodifluoromethane) is now used primarily within refrigeration and air conditioning systems as the working fluid. Some material is released into the atmosphere when these systems are first filled but the bulk of the losses occur subsequently during maintenance, or as the result of accidental damage or when the equipment is finally removed from service and scrapped. There are other minor uses in foam blowing and historical use in aerosol propellant formulations.

As a consequence of the delay between first use and release, it is necessary to calculate emissions from time series of data on production and sales into various end-use categories having different release functions. The calculation method is described in McCulloch et al. (2002).

Releases from hermetic refrigeration are normally distributed about an average of 10 years, so that complete emission occurs within 20 years. The emission function for non-hermetic refrigeration is faster, with an approximately normal distribution about a 4.5 year mean and complete emission within 10 years. Due to the nature of the plastic foam matrices, half of the material used in closed cell foam is emitted in the year of manufacture and half in the following year. The emission function for Aerosols and others provides for 50% release in the year of manufacture and the rest in the year following and the corresponding value for open cell foam is 83% in the year of manufacture. Emissions do not depend on the season of the year.

Basic Data on Sales

There is no single data set for global sales of any of the fluorocarbons. That compiled by industry (AFEAS, 2001) is compound specific and audited to ensure quality control, but has incomplete geographical coverage; production in China, India, Korea and Russia is not included. The data on production and consumption (the latter equating to sales) compiled by the United Nations Environment Programme to verify the application of the Montreal Protocol are neither compound specific nor audited although they do cover all parties to the Protocol (UNEP, 2002). UNEP data are reported as the aggregate total of all CFCs in ODPtonnes (Ozone Depletion Potential multiplied by metric tonnes). Submissions by individual countries are incorporated into the UNEP database with no further checks and reported values have been revised, without explanation, several years after they were first submitted.

These data sets have been amalgamated to provide global consumption values with defined quality and uncertainty and the distributed emissions described here were based on McCulloch et al. (1994).

Geographical Distribution of Emissions

The calculated global emissions of CFC-12 were distributed among countries using the distribution of individual national fractions of the world total Gross Domestic Product, as described in McCulloch et al. (1994). Within each country, emissions were distributed to individual gridsquares using a population distribution from Harvard University (Jennifer Logan, personal communication).

Results are presented here as the percentage distribution among gridsquares. Absolute emission from each gridsquare in 1986 should be calculated by multiplying global emission for 1986 in Table 1 (CFC12EM) by the gridsquare percentages in Table 2 (CFC1286yr1.1a). For other years, the distribution in Table 2 should be applied to the global emission for the appropriate year. While global emissions change relatively rapidly, distribution is affected only by relative economic activity and population dynamics, which have slower rates of change with time. It is expected that the distribution can be applied to the years 1980 to 1990 without significantly increasing uncertainty but this has not been tested. It can be applied to years beyond this range only with caution and new distributions for more recent years are under development.

Time Series of Global Emissions

Taken from McCulloch et al., 2002 (itself compiled from AFEAS, 2001 and UNEP, 2002), the time series (1930 to 2000) of CFC-12 emissions and their uncertainties is shown in Table 1 .

Future emissions will be governed by the controls required by the Montreal Protocol and by the quantity of material currently in the "bank" (that is: material which is in use but has not yet been emitted). A scenario for future releases of CFC-12 was described in Madronich and Velders (1999). This scenario has been updated and will be published in Fraser and Montzka (2003).

Development

In view of the changes brought about by the Montreal Protocol, it is proposed to revise the distribution functions to provide gridded data for the year 2000.

A. McCulloch
University of Bristol, UK
mailing address:
Barrymore, Marbury Road, Comberbach, Northwich, CW9 6AU, UK
phone/fax: +44-1606-891604
e-mail: archie@marbury.u-net.com

Table

Year Annual CFC-12 emission, Mg
Mean + 2 SD - 2 SD
1930 0 0 -
1931 0 100 -
1932 0 100 -
1933 100 200 -
1934 200 400 -
1935 300 600 -
1936 500 1000 -
1937 800 1700 -
1938 1100 2200 0
1939 1700 3100 200
1940 2200 3900 500
1941 3000 5100 800
1942 3600 5900 1400
1943 4500 7200 1800
1944 6100 11000 1100
1945 7900 14600 1300
1946 13900 19100 8700
1947 21300 25800 16800
1948 24700 28100 21300
1949 26600 28900 24200
1950 29400 31700 27200
1951 32300 35000 29700
1952 33600 36400 30900
1953 37800 41700 34000
1954 42800 47500 38200
1955 48100 53900 42400
1956 56100 63500 48700
1957 63800 71800 55800
1958 66900 75400 58300
1959 74700 83300 66200
1960 89000 97400 80600
1961 100000 108400 91700
1962 115400 123600 107300
1963 135600 143600 127600
1964 157800 165600 149900
1965 177900 187200 168500
1966 199500 211000 188100
1967 225100 238300 211900
1968 252500 266500 238500
1969 281800 297200 266300
1970 307800 324800 290800
1971 331600 349800 313500
1972 362100 382500 341800
1973 401100 424500 377800
1974 435100 459400 410700
1975 423700 445400 402100
1976 413600 437900 389300
1977 401300 434300 368400
1978 376700 413300 340200
1979 375900 413500 338300
1980 379900 415400 344300
1981 394000 427000 361100
1982 403100 430200 376100
1983 417000 441300 392600
1984 439200 464100 414300
1985 449900 472900 427000
1986 460200 484200 436200
1987 463100 492900 433300
1988 451800 488100 415500
1989 418700 458100 379300
1990 367100 396300 337800
1991 336600 363700 309600
1992 319900 342800 296900
1993 300500 317900 283000
1994 277000 - 239800
1995 255500 - 187800
1996 233100 - 140300
1997 207700 - 99800
1998 182000 - 74000
1999 155200 - 53600
2000 134100 - 29300

Table 1: Global Emissions of CFC-12 (dichlorodifluoromethane) from 1930 to 2000

Data in Mg (millions of grams or metric tonnes),  SD=Standard Deviation
Compiled by A. McCulloch (archie@marbury.u-net.com)

Based on:
McCulloch A., P.M. Midgley and P. Ashford
Releases of Refrigerant Gases (CFC-12, HCFC-22 and HFC-134a) to the Atmosphere
submitted to Atmos. Environ., 2002.

Production, Sales and Atmospheric Releases of Fluorocarbons through 2000,
Alternative Fluorocarbons Environmental Acceptability Study, Arlington, VA, USA, 2001.

Production and Consumption of Ozone Depleting Substances, 1986-2000,
Secretariat to the Montreal Protocol, United Nations Environment Programme, Nairobi, Kenya, 2002.

References

AFEAS (Alternative Fluorocarbons Environmental Acceptability Study) Production, Sales and Atmospheric Releases of Fluorocarbons through 2000, AFEAS, Arlington, VA, USA, 2001 (see www.afeas.org).

Fraser P. and S. Montzka, Controlled Substances and Other Source Gases, Ch. 1 of Scientific Assessment of Ozone Depletion: 2002, in preparation, WMO, Geneva, 2003.

Madronich S. and G.J.M. Velders, Halocarbon Scenarios for the Future Ozone Layer and Related Consequences, Ch. 11 of Scientific Assessment of Ozone Depletion: 1998, World Meteorological Organization Ozone Research and Monitoring Project Report No 44, WMO, Geneva, 1999.

McCulloch A., P.M. Midgley and D.A. Fisher, Distribution of emissions of chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs) 11, 12, 113, 114 and 115 among reporting and non-reporting countries in 1986, Atmos. Environ., 28(16), 2567-2582, 1994.

McCulloch A., P.M. Midgley and P. Ashford, Releases of Refrigerant Gases (CFC-12, HCFC-22 and HFC-134a) to the Atmosphere, submitted to Atmospheric Environment, 2002.

UNEP (United Nations Environment Programme), Production and Consumption of Ozone Depleting Substances, 1986-2000, Secretariat to the Montreal Protocol, UNEP, Nairobi, Kenya, 2002 (see www.unep.org/ozone).



(last modified 02/20/05)